Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice


Online marketing campaign optimization strategies evolve.

Some of us bear in mind effectively the instances when a majority of advertisements have been bought by reservation of a time slot on a webpage.

The advertiser paid, say, a month-to-month price for a horizontal banner on the house web page of a particular portal. The house for optimization was very restricted.

From CPM to Profit Optimization

The first easy advert servers allowed rotation of the advertisements and counting of impressions, attain, and frequency. Advertisers began utilizing CPM (price per thousand impressions) optimization.

However, the impressions have been generally exhausting to check, particularly in the case of various sizes and positions of the advertisements, subsequently advertisers began to optimize the precise visitors delivered by the advertisements and their CPC (price per click on).

Soon it turned apparent, that the standard of visitors additionally issues.

What guests truly do on the advertiser’s web site and what number of desired actions, corresponding to buy or signup (conversions), the visitors generates have to be rigorously monitored.

Conversion monitoring programs made attainable optimization of CPA (price per motion). Then, assigning a worth to the conversion began the ROI (return on funding) period when advertisers began to check the precise revenue from the acquired visitors and price of its buy.

However, ROI will not be the reply.

Many promoting businesses current case research with monumental ROI, however because it normally applies to a restricted marketing campaign and it must be handled fairly as an anomaly.

Today’s internet marketing market is extremely environment friendly. It implies that normally, the price of promoting displays its worth. Real bargains are uncommon and shortly disappear.

Today’s entrepreneurs face the basic “margin or volume” dilemma. The advertisers with low budgets and low quantity expectations can begin from the most affordable placements and low frequency.

Increasing quantity requires shopping for increasingly more costly placements, increased frequency, and better advert place in search engine advertisements.

For this motive, the effectivity (ROI) of the advert decreases as the amount grows.

The common rule is that large gamers don’t purchase cheaper, nevertheless it’s truly the alternative.

The extra intense the promoting is, the upper the prices per impression, click on, and conversion.

The whole revenue (revenue from marketing campaign much less its price) initially will increase, however the increased the amount is, the slower the expansion.

At a sure level because the income begin to lower, we are saying the advertiser has overinvested in the advertisements.

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

The thrust of promoting optimization goals for the candy spot of most revenue discovered between under- and overinvestment areas.

Profit-driven optimization is essentially the most superior and supreme objective of price range and bid administration.

Price Elasticity

Price elasticity is a measure used in economics to point out how the demand or provide responds to a change in worth. It is the share change in amount demanded or provided in response to a one p.c change in worth.

If the availability is the visitors purchased by promoting (clicks) and the value is price per click on (CPC), the elasticity measures how the visitors responds to a change in CPC (d stands for small enhance of the worth):

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

The increased the worth of the fraction, the upper the elasticity is. If the elasticity is lower than one, it’s stated that the demand or provide is inelastic.

Price elasticity exhibits how briskly the amount of clicks (and conversions) reacts to a change of unit worth (CPC or CPA).

Say, a marketing campaign generates 1,000 clicks at CPC $1, and after enhance of CPC to $.1.10 (i.e., +10%), the clicking quantity grows to 1,200 (+20%). In this case, the elasticity is comparatively excessive and equals to 2:

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

Another instance: If the rise bids by +20% outcomes in +10% progress of click on quantity, the elasticity is the same as 0.5.

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

The worth elasticity in on-line advertisements normally decreases with worth. Increasing CPC (or CPM) bids will increase the volumes, however the relative progress will get smaller and smaller.

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

Price elasticity (E) is without doubt one of the most vital metrics for SEM bid administration.

The level of the utmost revenue is the place the ROI = 1/E, and rising CPC bids is sensible provided that ROI > 1/E. Otherwise, the bids must be decreased.

The worth elasticity in Google Ads and different search engine promoting programs relies upon primarily on the place of the advert.

High positions on the highest of the web page normally have very low elasticity.

If the typical place of the advert is 1.three and it has a 99.9% impression share and it exhibits up in 97% of the events on the high of the web page, rising the CPC bid can’t considerably change the variety of clicks.

On the opposite hand, the very best elasticity happens when the advert begins to look on the primary web page.

However, the excessive relative enhance of visitors, in this case, outcomes from the low visitors from advertisements displayed on the second web page of the search outcomes.

Even a low positioned advert on the primary web page usually acquires many extra clicks.

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

Increase of elasticity happens additionally when the place of the advert grows and the advert strikes to the highest of the search outcome web page.

The CTR on the highest is normally 10 to 20 instances increased than for the “other” placements in the search outcomes web page.

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

Therefore, advertisements with a low impression share as a result of rank (indicating that the bid is usually under first web page bid), advertisements with a low advert place, in addition to advertisements with few “top” impressions, all have increased elasticity.

Bid simulator and Google Ads experiments assist to find out the precise worth of the value elasticity, as described in this text on this matter.

Practical Implications

How does this affect SEM bid administration observe?

Usually the advertiser set an arbitrary objective of a sure CPA or ROI, and the price range and bid choices are modified in order to attain it.

If the supply, marketing campaign, advert group or key phrase brings costly conversions, the budgets are decreased or canceled.

If the conversion price is low, or the ROI excessive, the budgets are elevated in order to accumulate extra low-cost conversions.

This is how many people optimize, don’t we? And it’s not precisely the optimum.

Keywords usually have totally different conversion charges.

The highest conversion charges normally happen in case of brand name key phrases (i.e., if the consumer is looking for the advertiser’s title or title of the supplied product). This isn’t shocking, because the consumer intent may be very particular.

The non-brand key phrases, relying on relevancy, may have increased or decrease conversion charges.

The low changing key phrases, nevertheless, could also be utilized by the advertiser, as a result of the ROI could also be nonetheless optimistic with a low CPC, which can be attainable to attain with worse advert positions.

So, the key phrases have totally different CPC bids and positions. The impression loss as a result of advert rank and the share of high impressions may also be totally different in the case of various key phrases, and subsequently the value elasticity can be additionally totally different.

The ROI > 1/E mannequin exhibits that the one issue figuring out the optimum goal ROI is worth elasticity. For this motive, an arbitrary objective of mounted ROI for all the marketing campaign wouldn’t be optimum.

Keywords with low elasticity ought to have excessive ROI, whereas key phrases with excessive elasticity might have decrease ROI. Moreover, the goal ROI must be set as 1/E, so the goal ROI is definitely not a matter of the advertiser’s alternative.

Using a set and arbitrary ROI or CPA outcomes in overinvestment in greatest changing key phrases (e.g., model key phrases) and underinvestment in most common key phrases.

In nearly all of large model SEM campaigns I’ve audited, the model key phrase bids have been pumped to the intense, whereas the opposite key phrases have been on the border of the first-page bid, as in the instance under:

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

If understanding the that means of worth elasticity, as an alternative of pursuing the identical ROI targets, we might use totally different ROI targets for various key phrase teams, the outcomes of the marketing campaign may appear to be this:

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

The variety of conversions has elevated and, on the similar time, its price has decreased.

The Paradox of Expensive Traffic Source

The software of profit-driven optimization might look counterintuitive. Instead of accelerating bids and funding in the most effective changing key phrases, the alternative truly occurs.

The funding in the very best changing, however overinvested key phrases is decreased, and the cash saved is used to extend the budgets of “less attractive” however underinvested key phrases with decrease conversion charges.

These underinvested key phrases have excessive worth elasticity and subsequently elevated funding outcomes in a comparatively excessive enhance in quantity.

On the opposite hand, a considerably smaller funding in overinvested key phrases outcomes in a comparatively small loss in quantity.

Each key phrase has its personal worth elasticity (E) and, for that reason, ought to have totally different goal ROI = 1/E.

Yet if the key phrases are grouped in a few teams of comparable elasticity, and separate ROI targets are used for these teams, the bid administration can be far more environment friendly.

The absolute minimal is to separate the model and non-brand key phrases.

See one other instance. An advertiser runs two campaigns, one in Google and the opposite on Facebook. The CPA on Facebook ($20 ) seems excessive in comparability to the CPA in Google ($12):

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

Therefore, the advertiser decides to pause the marketing campaign on Facebook and as an alternative, make investments extra in Google Ads:

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

But wait!

After this “optimization”, the full variety of conversions is smaller, whereas the fee is increased than earlier than. This is as a result of the marginal CPA of Google marketing campaign was:

($19,500 – $12,000) / (1300 – 1000) = $7,500 / 300 = $25

This is increased than the CPA of the Facebook marketing campaign ($25).

Actually, it was extra worthwhile to extend the Facebook price range, as a result of it produced +20 extra conversions with decrease price ($26 much less) than increased funding in Google:

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

Marginal CPA of the Facebook marketing campaign was:

($7,474 – $7,000) / (370 – 350) = $474 / 20 = $23.7

This is decrease than the marginal CPA in Google ($25).

Marginal CPA calculations make it clear, however at first sight, it doesn’t look apparent that it’s extra environment friendly to take a position in the marketing campaign with worse CPA.

Real Life: How to Work with Fixed CPA Targets

In observe, entrepreneurs not often know the true ROI of their advertisements.

Even in the event that they know the precise revenue and ROI from a transaction, they normally don’t know its lifetime worth (LTV), or the LTV is barely a tough estimation.

More typically they work inside a CPA or ROI goal, the place ROI is calculated with out utilizing the LTV components.

Should the advertiser set a “non-negotiable” ROI (or CPA) goal, utilizing it for all campaigns is rarely optimum.

It doesn’t make good business sense to push the most effective changing campaigns to the restrict, reaching factors of low elasticity the place the fee grows shortly whereas the results enhance barely.

It is healthier to set increased ROI targets for these campaigns the place the elasticity is low and on the similar time settle for decrease ROI for campaigns with increased elasticity.

By deciding on totally different ROI targets for various campaigns, advert teams, and key phrases, we are able to nonetheless obtain the specified common ROI, however the whole variety of conversions can be increased.

This is as a result of we lose just some conversions and save important cash on the much less elastic marketing campaign, and the cash saved brings far more extra conversions if invested in extra elastic campaigns, even when their ROI is decrease.

Therefore, even when we now have to work inside a given ROI goal, it isn’t optimum to have one goal ROI for all sources, campaigns, key phrases, units and different biddable gadgets.

Using totally different ROI targets relying on elasticity is the essential precept of portfolio bidding.

Mathematical fashions might assist to calculate related changes to the goal ROI, however in observe, we should use machine-learning optimizers who embrace this idea and discover “trade-offs and hidden opportunities.” (See Search Ads 360 assist article right here.)

Elasticity changes might clarify elevated bids for lesser performing biddable gadgets, made to enhance total efficiency.

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

Elasticity in Display Advertising

The idea of profit-driven advertising will be additionally used in show promoting.

Display advertisements may also be optimized by bid and placement choice and frequency capping.

More and dearer placement will be achieved by rising bids, and in this fashion, it resembles search promoting. However, a change in bids might change the precise construction of placements and audiences, too.

Different placements and audiences might have totally different conversion charges and totally different conversion prices, versus search engine advertisements the place the conversion charge doesn’t rely on the place of the advert.

Regardless of the advert place, the SEM advertisements are clicked by the identical individuals who search for a similar key phrases utilizing the identical search engine.

Therefore, the value elasticity of conversions could also be a perform with many native maxima and minima.

However, in the macroscale, show advertisements may also present lowering elasticity.

There are many theories in regards to the optimum frequency capping that advertisers ought to use. These theories normally say that the “best” frequency is between two and 5 instances per distinctive consumer.

However, if we measure the advert effectivity utilizing CTR, a metric that measures the grade of the customers’ response to the advert, we normally can see that to a novel consumer every subsequent impression has a smaller affect.

The instance attain and frequency report from Google Ads (Display) exhibits that the CTR decreases with each impression.

Lowering CTR causes rising of CPC. The effectivity of the marketing campaign decreases, and we now have decrease and decrease response. The “unit price” grows.

Profit-Driven PPC Management in Practice

Unfortunately, this Google Ads report has been discontinued, and we don’t have entry to such detailed insights now.

However, we are able to nonetheless observe the modifications in CTR and CPC relying on the frequency.

Whenever the frequency is excessive, we might anticipate that the elasticity of a marketing campaign to be low, and even when the present ROI is sweet, rising frequency capping might carry only some extra conversions.

It could also be higher to extend the frequency of much less worthwhile marketing campaign with low frequency.

More Resources:


Image Credits

All screenshots taken by writer, June 2019



Tags: , , ,